Many nonprofit organizations include several charitable purposes in their articles of association, even though they do not pursue all of them at the same time. This regularly creates uncertainty in dealings with the tax authorities. We explain why these so-called “reserve purposes” are generally permissible from a legal standpoint and what organizations in Germany should keep in mind in practice.
Importance of charitable purposes in German association and foundation law
Under German association and foundation law, the articles of association form the central basis for charitable status. They define the tax-privileged purposes pursued by the nonprofit organization and serve as the benchmark for review by the tax authorities. In practice, articles of association often contain multiple purposes, for example to allow flexibility in responding to social developments or to avoid future amendments. In many cases, however, these purposes are not implemented simultaneously. These are referred to as reserve purposes, meaning purposes that are currently inactive but may be pursued in the future.
Many board members and managing directors worry that this could jeopardize the organization’s charitable status. While this concern is understandable, it is often unfounded as a matter of law. Neither association law nor foundation law requires all stated purposes to be pursued at all times or to the same extent. What matters instead is that the organization as a whole operates for charitable purposes and documents this transparently to the outside world.
Actual management: The standard used by the tax authority in assessing charitable status
The key focus of any charitable status review is the organization’s actual management. This refers to how the organization implements its stated purposes in practice. The tax authorities review activity reports, annual financial statements, meeting minutes or website content to determine whether the organization pursues its tax-privileged purposes exclusively and directly. “Exclusively” means that no non-charitable objectives are pursued, while “directly” means that the organization itself actively carries out the activities.
The fact that certain purposes may not be pursued for a period of time is not, in itself, problematic. It only becomes critical if no charitable activity at all is evident over an extended period or if a purpose has effectively been abandoned without updating the articles of association accordingly.
Would you like to receive news like this in your inbox every month? Subscribe to our newsletter “German Nonprofit Update”.
Structuring reserve purposes in a legally sound way: Recommendations for maintaining charitable status
Reserve purposes in articles of association generally do not pose a risk to charitable status, provided there is a genuine intention to pursue them in the medium term. The decisive factor is that at least one stated purpose is actually, continuously, and transparently implemented in practice. Based on our experience in advising nonprofit organizations in Germany, we recommend avoiding unnecessarily overloaded articles of association while still preserving strategic flexibility. Equally important is maintaining clear documentation of the organization’s actual activities, particularly where multiple stated purposes are involved.
WINHELLER supports you with questions regarding your articles of association
Is your nonprofit organization in Germany uncertain whether inactive purposes could become problematic? Are you wondering whether an amendment to your articles of association is really necessary or how to document the implementation of your purposes in a legally sound manner? Or would you like to future-proof your articles of association without putting your charitable status at risk? Our NPO team would be happy to advise you individually and with a practical focus. Please contact us any time!
