info@winheller.com+49 (0)69 76 75 77 80Mon. - Fri. from 8am to 8pm, Sat. from 8am to 5pm

Cookie Permissions Must Be Actively Ticked in Germany

Jun 30, 20 • IT Law, Privacy LawNo Comments

Cookie Permissions Must Be Actively Ticked in GermanyNowadays, many websites use cookies to track user behavior or to display customized advertising. Anyone wishing to take advantage of the benefits associated with these cookies must obtain the users’ consent.

In the opinion of the German Federal Court of Justice (BGH), pre-crossed buttons on websites are not sufficient. Consent would be invalid in this case. Instead, the check must be actively set.

What are cookies?

Cookies assign individual identifiers to the users of websites. This enables these websites to recognize visitors. In many cases, however, they also evaluate user behavior. In most cases, users must agree to the use of cookies beforehand. Once consent has been given, information is stored on the user’s terminal device or their data is accessed.

Agreement must be active

According to the BGH, consent is only effective if it has been actively given by the user (so-called opt-in).

An online gambling provider had informed users about the use of cookies in a prescribed consent text. The cookies were to be used to evaluate the surfing and usage behavior of the lottery participants on websites of advertising partners by an advertising analysis service. The consent was already preset because it was marked with a tick in the corresponding field from the beginning. However, the users could remove it themselves (so-called opt-out).

ECJ interprets consent in a user-friendly way

According to the German Telemedia Act (TMG), the use of cookies to create user profiles for advertising or market research purposes is permitted if the user does not object to this. However, the basic data protection regulation requires active consent.

After initial uncertainties as to how the term consent is to be interpreted, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) asked the European Court of Justice (ECJ) for clarification. The ECJ decided that active consent does not apply to a pre-filled checkbox, which the user must uncheck to refuse consent.

Extensive protection of privacy

The BGH also made it clear in its ruling that consent does not depend on whether the information stored and retrieved is personal data. This is because European laws protect not only personal data, but the privacy of internet users as a whole.

Threat of ineffective consent and unnecessary expenses

As a result, the gambling provider was not only ordered to refrain from this consent practice, but also had to pay the plaintiff’s dunning expenses.

This shows that a lawful implementation of cookie consent not only provides protection against subsequent adjustments and invalid consent, but also saves additional costs. Moreover, it is to be expected that supervisory authorities will take action and sanction the previous practice where consent was given by clicking “Ok” or by using pre-filled cookie banners.

Our experts will be happy to offer comprehensive advice on the use of cookies on your website.

Continue reading:
Companies May Issue Warnings of GDPR Violations in Germany
Data Protection Compliance in Germany in Three Steps

Olga Stepanova

Olga Stepanova

Attorney Olga Stepanova works for Winheller in the areas of IT law, intellectual property and data protection. Her main fields of expertise include trademark law, copyright law, and competition law.

>> show profile

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WINHELLER Blog via Newsletter

Subscribe to our free newsletter and receive regular updates on German business law by e-mail. (Mandatory fields are marked with *)

German Business Law News (4 times a year)
I would like to subscribe to the selected newsletter and for that purpose give my consent to WINHELLER to process my above mentioned data. I have read the "Information for Data Processing in the Newsletter Subscription". I understand that I can revoke my consent at any time with effect for the future by clicking the unsubscribe button within the newsletter. *